The first reported medieval judicial autopsy on Azzolino Degli Onesti: poisoning or Budd-Chiari syndrome?

Main Article Content

Luigi Papi

Keywords

history of autopsy, Budd Chiaru Syndrome

Abstract

The practice of autopsy on human corpses performed to increase anatomical and physio-pathological knowledge has been reported since ancient times, even if it has often been opposed by medical theories and religious beliefs. The first officially autopsy reported in Italy was that described by Salimbene on 1286 during an epidemy that involved hens and human beings.


The development of medico-legal practice on cadavers dates back to the Middle Age in Bologna, the city that boasted the most advanced medical and legal faculties of that period. Some of these autopsy reports have come down to our times and provide interesting information on the medico-legal procedures of that period.


In particular, it is illustrated the case of Azzolino degli Onesti: his death was suspected for poisoning but the interpretation of the autopsy report based on current medical knowledge may suggest different conclusions.

Abstract 21 | PDF Downloads 20

References

King LS, Meehan MC. A history of the autopsy. A review, American Journal of Pathology, 1973;73(2):513-544.
Dawson WR, Egypt’s place in medical history. Science, medicine and history: essays on the evolution of scientific thought and medical practice written in honour of Charles Singer (1953) 1:47-60.
Cecchetto G, Bajanowski T, Cecchi R, Favretto D, Grabherr S, Ishikawa T, Kondo T, Montisci M, Pfeiffer H, Rippa Bonati M, Shokry D, Vennemann M, Ferrara SD. Back to the Future - Part 1. The medico-legal autopsy from ancient civilization to the post-genomic era. Int J Legal Med (2017) 131:1069-1083.
Wiltse LL, Pait TG. Historical perspective. Herophilus of Alexandria (325-255 B. C.). The Father of Anatomy, Spine 1998;23(17):1904-1914.
Potter P. Herophilus of Chalcedon: An assessment of his place in the history of anatomy. Stevenson L, ed. Bulletin of the history of medicine 1976;50:45-60.
Robinson V. The Story of Medicine. New York: Tudor Publishing Co., 1931:67-72.
Dobson JF, Herophylus of Alexandria. Proceedings of The Royal Society of Medicine 1925;18:19-32.
Von Stadet H, The discovery of the body human dissection and its cultural contexts in Ancient Greece. The Yale Journal Of Biology And Medicine 1992;65:223-241.
Bliquez LJ, Kazhdan A, Four testimonia to human dissection in Byzantine Times. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 1984;58(4): 554-557.
Tweel JG, Taylor CR. The rise and fall of the autopsy. Virchows Arch 2013;462:371-380.
Malmesburiensis W (1125) Gesta regum Anglorum. Edition Sir Thomas Duffus Hardy, Lib. V 639-640. http://archive.org/details/willelmimalmesbi02will.
Burton JL. A Bite into the history of the autopsy from ancient roots to modern decay, Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology, 2005:VI (4):277-284.
Binski P. Medieval Death, Ritual and Representation. London British Museum Press, 1996.
Salimbene de Adam, Cronica, I vol., ed. Giuseppe Scalia (Bari, 1966), II, 894.
Greco E. Studi e ricerche su Fra Salimbene da Parma descrittore nella sua cronica della prima necropsia fatta a scopo anatomopatologico nel 1286. Minerva Med 1961;52:3361-3364.
Hirt M, Kovàc P., History of forensic medicine-the second part. The autopsy in the Middle Age and the Renaissance. Soud Lek. 2005;50(3):32-7.
Brown EAR, Death and the human body in the later Middle Ages: the Legislation of Boniface VIII on the division of the corpse, Viator 1981;12:221-70.
O’Neill YV, Innocent III and the evolution of anatomy, Med Hist 1976;20(4):429-433.
Duranti T, Reading the Corpse in the Late Middle Ages (Bologna, Mid-13th Century-Early 16th Century), in De Ceglia FP, The Body of evidence - Medieval and Early Modem Philosophy and Science (vol. 30), ed. Brill, Leiden/Boston: 71-104.
Park K. The life of the Corpse: division and dissection in Late Medieval Europe. The Journal of the history of medicine and allied sciences 1995(50): 11-132.
Singer C. A short history of Anatomy and Physiology from the Greeks to Harvey. New York, Dover Publications Inc, 1957, p 72
We can find them in the Divina Commedia by Dante Alighieri, Inf. XXIII, 104.
“Sensibiliter cognoverunt visceribus eius anathomice circumspectis”; “Predictum Azzolinum ex veneno aliquo mortuum non fuisse, sed potius et certius ex multitudine sanguinis agregati circa venam magnam, que dicitur vena chilis et vena epatis propinquas eidem, unde prohibita fuit spiritus quia ipsum in totum corpus efluxio et facta caloris innati in toto mortifficatio sive extincio”.
Valla DC. The diagnosis and management of the Budd-Chiari syndrome: consensus and controversies. Hepatology 2003;38:793-803.
Tanaka M, Wanless IR. Pathology of the liver in Budd-Chiari syndrome: portal vein thrombosis and the histogenesis of veno-centric cirrhosis, veno-portal cirrhosis, and large regenerative nodules. Hepatology 1998; 27: 488-496.
Aydinli M, Bayraktar Y,Budd-Chiari syndrome: etiology, pathogenesis and diagnosis, World J Gastroenterol 2007 May 21; 13(19): 2693-2696.