Bone grafting in the pre-antiseptic era (historical review) Part 1. Beginning of the journey. From antiquity to the 1860 .

Main Article Content

Alexander Pankratov
Astemir Shajhaliev

Keywords

bone graft, periosteum, ossification, transplantation, amputation, bone defect, regeneration process, replantation

Abstract

In this paper, a systematic review of the state of bone plastic surgery was carried out before the antiseptic approach was widely introduced into world clinical practice. The experience of the first bone transplantation operations is analyzed in their relationship with the development of ideas about the regenerative regeneration of bone tissue. It is shown that, contrary to generally accepted ideas, it was at that time that the theoretical and practical foundation was laid, without which it would have been impossible to develop bone grafting in the following decades, discoveries were made, the significance of which could be understood only a century later. The first part of the article traces the background of the issue, starting with the earliest archaeological finds dating back to the II millennium BC, until the early 1860s, when the first theories began to be created, systematizing the observations accumulated by that time, and predetermined the formation of the future direction of medical science.

Abstract 15 | PDF Downloads 18

References

1. Dreyer CH, Rasmussen M, Pedersen RH, Overgaard S, Ding M. Comparisons of Ef-ficacy between Autograft and Allograft on Defect Repair In Vivo in Normal and Os-teoporotic Rats. Biomed Res Int. 2020 Mar 3;2020:9358989. doi: 10.1155/2020/9358989 PMID: 32190690
2. Rinaldi, E. The first homoplastic limb transplant according to the legend of Saint Cosmas and Saint Damian. Ital. J. Orthop. Traumatol. 1987.13, 394–406 PM-ID: 3330728
3. de Boer H.H. The history of bone grafts. Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res.1988; 226: 292-298 PMID: 3275515
4. Glicenstein J. History of Bone Reconstruction. [Histoire de la reconstruction osseuse] Ann Chir Plast Esthet . 2000; 45: 171-174 PMID: 10929451 (in French)
5. Mankin H.J., Hornicek F.J., Gebhardt M.C., Tomford W.W. Bone Allograft Trans-plantation. Theory and Practice. In Bone Regeneration and Repair: Biology and Clin-ical Applications/ ed. by J.R. Lieberman, G.F. Friedlander. Totowa, New Jersey. Hu-mana Press, 2005: 241-261
6. Horowitz R. A., Leventis M.D., Rohrer M.D., Prasad H.S. Bone grafting: history, rationale, and selection of materials and techniques Compend Contin Educ Dent . 2014;35:1-6; PMID: 25455148
7. Donati D., Zolezzi C., Tomba P., Vigano A. Bone grafting: historical and conceptual review, starting with an old manuscript by Vittorio Putti. Acta Orthopedica 2007; 78(1): 19-25 DOI 10.1080/17453670610013376
8. Albee F.H. Bone-Graft Surgery. Philadelphia-London. W.B. Saunders Company, 1915 – 417p.
9. Macewen W. Observations concerning Transplantation of Bone. Illustrated by Case of Inter-human Osseous Transplantation, whereby over two-thirds of the Shaft of a Humerus was restored. Proceeding of the Royal Society of London. 1881; 32: 232-247
10. Brink O. The choice between allograft or demineralized bone matrix is not unambiguous in trauma surgery. Injury 2021;52 Suppl 2:S23-S28. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2020.11.013
11. Güngörmüş Z., Güngörmüş M. Effect of religious belief on selecting of graft material used in oral and maxillofacial surgery. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2017; 75: 2347-2353 DOI: 10.1016/j.joms.2017.07.160
12. Maas W., Bienengraber V., Wolf E. Safe augmentation: Split-mouth case study on the augmentation of medium-sized bone defects. Implants 2006; 3: 10–5.
13. Aciduman A., Belen D. The earliest document regarding the history of cranioplasty from the Ottoman era. Surg Neurol. 2007;68(3): 349-352 doi.org/10.1016/j.surneu.2006.10.073
14. Shoja M.M., , Agutter P.S., , Loukas M., , Shokouhi G., Khalili M., Farhoudi M, Tubbs R.Sh. Cranioplasty in medieval Persia and the potential spread of this know-ledge to Europe. Childs Nerv Syst. 2012; 28: 1993-1996 doi.org/10.1007/s00381-012-1876-8
15. Meek’ren J. Medical and Surgical Observations. Translated by A.Blasio [Observa-tiones medico-chirurgicae. ex belgico in latinum translatae ab Abrahamo Blasio]. Amsterdam. Ex officina Henrici vidae Theodori Boom, 1682 – 392p. (in Latin)
16. Ollier L. Experimental and Clinical treatment of Bone Regeneration and artificial bone tissue production.[Traite Experimental et Clinique de la Regeneration des Os et de la production artificielle du tissue osseux]. In two tome. Paris. Victor Masson et Fils. 1867 – 443, 531p. (in French)
17. Havers C. Osteologia Nova: Or, Some New Observations of the Bones, and the Parts Belonging to Them. London. Printer to the Royal Society, at the Weft-End of St Paul’s, 1729 – 293p.
18. Belchier J An account of the bones of animals being changed to a red colour by aliment only. Philos Trans R Soc. 1736. 39:287–288
19. v Haller A. Experiences with the Callus of Bones. [Experiences fur le Cal des Os.] In Fougeroux M. Memoires sur les Os, Pour server de Response aux Objections propo-fees contre le fentimentde M. Duhamel du MONCEAU, rapporté dans les Volumes de l’Académie Royale des Sciences. Paris. H.L. Guerein & Delatour L.F., 1760: 148-188 (in French)
20. v Haller A. Experiences of bones formation.[Experimentorum de ossium formatione.] In Operum Anatomici argumenti minorum. T.2 Lausanne. Francisci Grasset, 1767: 460-600 (in Latin)
21. Bordenave M. On the Formation of Bones.[Sur la Formation des Os.] In Fougeroux M. Memoires sur les Os, Pour server de Response aux Objections propofees contre le fentimentde M. Duhamel du MONCEAU, rapporté dans les Volumes de l’Académie Royale des Sciences. Paris. H.L. Guerein & Delatour L.F., 1760: 191-240 (in French)
22. Bogdanovich U.YA. Materials on the development of bone grafting in Russia. [Materialy k voprosu o razvitii kostnoj plastiki v Rossii.] Dissertation. Kazan, 1957 – 225 p. (in Russian)
23. Muhin E.O.The first beginnings of bone-setting science. [Pervye nachala kostopravnoj nauki.] In 2 books, 5 parts. Moscow: Selivanovsky Printing house of , 1806 - 96,24,56,32,24p. (in Russian)
24. Rklickij I.V. A method of cutting out bones using a Heine osteotome with an explanation of the mechanism and the use of the most important parts of this instrument. [Sposob vypilivaniya kostej s pomoshch'yu Gejneva osteotoma s ob"yasneniem mekhanizma i upotrebleniya vazhnejshih chastej etogo instrumenta.] Dissertation. St. Petersburg: Eduard Pats Printing house, 1840 - 38p. (in Russian)
25. Bush I.F. Guide to teaching surgery.[ Rukovodstvo k prepodavaniyu hirurgii.] In 3 parts. St. Petersburg: Printing House A. Smirdina, 1833 – 452,677,681 p. (in Rus-sian)
26. Pirogov N.I. The basics of general battlefield surgery, taken from military-hospital practice and memories of the Crimean war and the Caucasus expedition. [Nachala obshchej voenno-polevoj hirurgii, vzyatye iz voenno-gospital'noj praktiki i vospomi-nanij o krimskoj vojne i kavkazskoj ekspedicii.] Volume II. Dresden: E. Blochmann and son Printing house, 1865-1866 - 629p. (in Russian)
27. Rudnev M.M. Replantation and transplantation of whole tubular bones and bone pieces. Experimental study. [O replantacii i transplantacii cel'nyh trubchatyh kostej i kostnyh kusochkov. Eksperimental'noe issledovanie.] Dissertation. St. Petersburg: Yakov Trey Printing house, 1880 - 49p. (in Russian)
28. Wolf J. Osteoplasty in its relations with surgery and physiology.[Die Osteoplastik in ihren Beziehungen zur chirurgie und physiologie.] Archiv fur Klinische Chirurgie. Hereusgegeben von B. Langenbeck. 1863: 183-294 (in Deitch)
29. Kosmovskij Yu.A. On wound healing after trepanation. [O zazhivlenii ran posle trepanacii.] Dissertation. St. Petersburg, Yakov Trey Printing House, 1871 - 29p. (in Russian)
30. Fluorance P. Experimental theory of bone formation [Theorie experimentale de la formation des os]. Paris. Chez J.-B. Bailliere, 1847 – 164p. (in French)
31. Gulliver G. On Necrosis; being an experimental enquire into the agency ascribed to the absorbents, in the removal of the sequestrum. Medico – Chirurgical Transactions. 1838; 3,June:1-19
32. Pirogov N.I. Bone-plastic elongation of the shin bones upon foot removal. [Kostnoplasticheskoe udlinenie kostej goleni pri vylushchenii stopy.] Moscow: Medgiz, 1952 – 76p. (in Russian)
33. Vladimirov V.Ya. Several new osteoplastic operations on the lower limb. [Neskol'ko novyh osteoplasticheskih operacij na nizhnej konechnosti.] Dissertation. Kazan: University Printing house, 1872 – 53p. (in Russian)
34. Shimanovskij Yu.K. Defending Gritti operation in word and deed. [Zashchita operacii Gritti slovom i delom.] Military medical journal. 1868;5:1-21; 253-270 (in Russian)
35. Shimanovskij Yu.K. A few new articles on amputations. [Neskol'ko novyh zametok ob amputaciyah] Military medical journal. 1859;75:367-422,495-553 (in Russian)
36. Rauer A.E., Mihel'son N.M. Facial plastic surgery. [Plasticheskie operacii na lice] Moscow: Medgiz, 1943- 256p. (in Russian)
37. Paramesh R.Ch., Belgal P.G., Mathew A.E. Access to anterior skull base via Le Fort I approach. J. of Surgery and Research. 2018;1:14-21DOI: 10.26502/jsr.1002003